Visit Bob's new blog — The Difficult Art of Tomorrow — launched in April 2013
Visit Bob's other blog — Reshaping Light — launched in May 2013

The following essays were provided to us by Bob for publicatiton here on his website

[November 2013 -- The following author notes were provided by Bob as an introduction to his new Fixup novel/collection The Greatship, available in e-book format in November 2013, and as a print-on-demand paperback in December 2013.]


   We are walking a line here.

   I want to be a help for my audience, but only to a point.

   Think of me as that old guy standing on the corner. You have a destination in mind, and after asking me for directions, I say with considerable certainty, “Head north.” But then I keep talking, loudly warning you that I don’t know how far you need to go before the first turn, or which way you turn after that, and I’m not familiar with the street you want, and indeed, I’m not entirely sure which piece of this gigantic horizon is the true North.

   THE GREATSHIP began as a tribe of previously published stories, and these stories haven’t been brutally altered from when they were first published. Each journey ends in the same place. Characters die or survive in the expected ways. But there has been some retooling to the language, and sometimes quite a bit of retooling, and the stories sit in a specific order that took a fair amount of consideration on part of the author. Question my choices all you wish. If the urge strikes, suggest other strategies to me. I might see your point and include your changes in the next version of this ongoing project...a topic that I’ll cover at the end of this rambling business.

   As with the two previous novels, MARROW and THE WELL OF STARS, I have begun with the Ship’s perspective. And throughout the book, I employ some version of the Ship’s voice to set the scene for the next chapter. Think of this as a framework. Think of these as being bridges between the small grand actions of people and aliens. That’s how I approach them, and every time I write a new bridge, I learn something that I didn’t see before.

   The first Great Ship story was “The Remoras”, and there was a temptation to start here with Quee Lee and Perri. Or for that matter, I could have offered up the young Washen in “Hoop-of-Benzene” or Mere’s long torment in “Mere”. But “Alone” has its merits, including gazing out at the universe with the eyes of a tiny and ancient and decidedly innocent creature. Tens of thousands of years are crossed, mostly on foot, and not only does the reader get glimpses of the empty Ship and then the Ship as it fills with people, but there is also some honest information about what the Great Ship really is as well as its linchpin importance in the scheme of Everything.

   A more rigorous mind might have gone back to the published stories as they appeared in the magazines and books, poring over them word by phrase. But my mind took a lazier, more emancipated course. When I had a digital file, I began with that. I saw what the editor saw when he or she bought the work. No copy editing. Just raw manuscript. I read the story while I wrote and I wrote while I read, and decisions were made on the fly, and later, once or twice more, I went back through that manuscript, polishing and cutting and sometimes, yes, referring to the original work just to be certain that I wasn’t screwing up things too badly.

    “Alone” was the first project, and that proved to be hard work. The original novella was written for Jonathan Strahan’s anthology about god-like machines. Nebulous troubles meant that Jonathan needed it fast, which meant six weeks, and I had to conceive the idea and bring it to a satisfactory conclusion while finishing another deadline story too. And because I know how goals can be hamstrung, I left myself extra time, in case of trouble. That’s why I wrote “Alone” in four weeks, about. Which is too fast for me, and afterwards I had to sit in a dark room for a week, doing nothing.

   The original work did fine critically and got reprinted and such...but when I tackled the rewriting, I immediately had troubles with language choices, with pace and flow. I now consider the older version to be a professional second draft. What you have in THE GREATSHIP is the fourth draft, plus some good hard thought about the entire story that I intend to tell for the rest of my professional life.

   Every story that I have ever written deserves another honest polish. I knew that going into this project, and I made my choices as I saw fit. Why this and not that? In some cases, I don’t know why. In others, I am prepared to defend my changes in front the Supreme Court, should the circumstance arise.

    “The Remoras” was the beginning of everything. Kris Rusch bought it for F&SF, and it garnered the cover. I never intended to build a long series off that one novelette, though I could see a sequel or two in the murky future. As with every story in THE GREATSHIP, one essential job was to strip out the excess from “The Remoras”. When a tale doesn’t stand alone, the reader doesn’t need to learn again about the Great Ship’s discovery or what the humans are doing with their prize. But the novelette demanded quite a bit more labor on top of the usual stripping. First of all, there was no digital file in my library. I didn’t back up the old floppies, which I’m sure will earn me my own corner of Hades, should anyone ever care. And that’s why I broke the spine on an old copy of F&SF, making the pages lie flat, and I rewrote it one keystroke at a time. Slower work than breezing through a digital file, yes, but informative to the author. Nearly twenty years of practice, and I found myself making small, sharp changes with the timing inside scenes, and even more critical, devising entirely new scenes that picture Quee Lee and Perri in their earliest days together.

    (I hate parentheses, as a rule. But this seems like an apropo moment. I know more about the Great Ship than anybody in the world, but I know very little. Yet just a couple months ago, with no warning, I suddenly realized something essential about Quee Lee and Perri. It explains quite a lot, and it will be pivotal in some future story. But why I couldn’t see the obvious truth before...well, I really don’t know much about anything, real or imaginary. Let’s just say that after twenty years, the perfect couple suddenly makes sense to me.)

    “Aeon’s Child” was another story that existed as paper, not as a digital file. Kris was given first shot at it, but she found Pamir to be unlikable. Gardner Dozois likes unlikable characters, and so “Child” ended up with ASIMOV’S. Like its predecessor, there was no digital file, which meant typing typing typing, and I remember having to do a lot combing and polish to make the prose feel finished. The same abuse happens to the same characters, but there is a chance that this version of Pamir, after my reworking, ends up being a little less of an asshole. Maybe Kris was right and I should have toned him down. Or maybe I’m just growing fond of the old grouse.

    “Night of Time” is the last example of a good honest write-through. I wrote it for a Golden Gryphon anthology, and there is a bit of an anecdote about the opening paragraph. I had some sweet mystical sentences to begin that story, and someone found them troubling and thought they should be removed. I wanted a sale and did it. I always intended to put the sentences back in some later edition. But I can’t find the original manuscript. Which isn’t to say that it doesn’t exist, and really, honestly, we all might be better off with what we have today. But there is this fond half-memory of some dreamy wonder, and there is the fear that I have lost a step, that I am not the writer than I used to be.

   There are changes in every story. Make no mistake. Some people might be amused to spend days and nights piecing together the differences. I hope nobody does that. But if you do, please don’t write me with questions about new phrasings that puzzle you or sentences that you loved but are now discarded. The universe of the Great Ship is built upon the Many Worlds scenario, and all of us should rest easy knowing that every version of these stories is published and happy somewhere.

   You also might notice missing stories. “Katabasis” and “Eater-of-Bone” haven’t made any appearance, to name two. But this project was conceived long enough ago that neither of those titles were available. Which brings us to another warning from the old man standing on the corner:

   This is a work that is not finished.

   I want to recalibrate THE GREATSHIP in the future, and probably more than once. New stories, new bridges, and more crowbars to the words when it becomes possible. Of course knowing that, you might not want to buy this version. An inferior “Beta” might distress you. But that’s why I don’t intend to ask for a tall pile of money, at least not for the digital version. This is a project that has always shown an urgent desire to grow over time, and the book will hopefully improve over the next decade or ten.

   Also missing is the original “Marrow”. Its exclusion is a very different matter. I changed the novella quite a lot when writing the novel of the same title, and while I have ideas for twists involving a rewritten version, for the time being, I would like to keep the possibilities vague. Think of “Marrow” as a half-dead cat inside a black box. Opening the lid is beyond my energy now.

   And here is another useful warning: I put this volume together as an e-book, but with no clear idea about how to get it out into the world. I probably would have done more finish work, and to that end, I let the file sleep for a few months on my hard drive. But then my agency, Writers House, got a deal with Argo Navis to publish e-books from known, established authors. And let’s just say that there was a good reason to get my book into the mix before the week was out.

   But then came the delays.

   Many months of delays, unfortunately. There are reasons, and I know some of the reasons, and really, they don’t matter much.

   But I shouldn’t delay any longer, I feel. I am sending out 170,000 plus words, pimples and all. You will find wrong words and the occasional dropped word. Not many dropped words, I hope, but they “exist” with the absence. Now I’m not apologizing for these goofs. Not quite. Think of me as that man on the corner. Before you continue with your journey, you want to use my bathroom. But now I am reminding you that I own a dog and he’s a big dog and stubborn and not particularly housebroken, and please watch where you’re walking while wandering across my property.

   My next genuinely finished book comes out in spring, from Prime Books.

   THE MEMORY OF SKY is polished to a high gloss, and it is at least as strange as anything in THE GREATSHIP. It is actually three novels pushed inside one volume, and it is very much part of the Marrow/Great Ship universe, and that is another reason for buying this e-book now. It is a good taste of what is to come.

   And now, my last warning:

   The title, THE GREATSHIP, is not a typo. I meant that word to be a single word, separating it from other Great Ships, wherever they may drift.

   Thank you, and the best to you.

— Robert Reed

November 3, 2013

[April 2013 -- Stories can begin with a compelling title, or the title is a last step in a writing process that makes the author feel like a baffled spectator.]


   I don’t remember using those four words in that particular order. I can’t recall them in my writing, or in my imagination either. But late last year, looking at deadlines and the hurdles of a busy holiday season, I was doing what I rarely do: Writing a point by point outline of a future work. This character would do that, and that action would result in this terrible thing happening, and oh, it became apparent that a new point of view had to be added. Readers deserved to understand the aliens. Except I didn’t know much about them either, which led to some long thoughts about the magnificent coronas. And that’s when I first jotted down the phrase, “Memory of sky.”

   For a very long moment, I did nothing.

   “Well,” I finally decided, “that’s got to be it.”

   Near the novel’s end, a title finally surfaces.

   And now, a little history.

   A few years ago, I wrote a novel aimed at an imaginary 12 year-old. I titled the book DIAMOND, and I was basically pleased with the effort. And so was the first editor, who very much wanted to buy it. Unfortunately, editors are subject to publishers and bookkeepers and other professional cowards, and the point was made — a fair point, really — that DIAMOND might be rather slow for the target audience. There wasn’t a lot of plot and not very much in the way of explanation. But what I wrote was exactly what I intended to write: One day in the life of a mysterious boy, a boy unlike any other, traveling through a beautiful world that is similar to ours, and is nothing like ours.

   Eventually that editor moved to another coast and a better job, and DIAMOND was shopped to a frisky new market called Amazon. They wanted to get into publishing without the cumbersome middle-folk. I was offered better terms than most of their writers, which is almost nothing. I soon had a contract to sign whenever the urge struck. But the urge was eluding me. Where would these books be sold? Besides on the Internet, I mean. Because Barnes and Noble had made it plain that Amazon titles would be banned. And what kind of editing and publicity would my work receive? Editing was a luxury that I’d have to pay for, I heard. And while publicity was guaranteed, those promises came without numbers or a track record or any other hopeful sign of real effort.

   Late in 2011, I was trading e-mails with Sean Wallace at Prime Books, and in the course of other topics, I mentioned my DIAMOND novel. Sean wanted to see it, and he read it and liked it well enough that he wanted two more novels in that world.

   That was a contract worth signing.

   At first, the plan was to publish one title every six months. The first two novels would have come out this year, 2013, and the last would appear early in 2014. It seemed like a worthy strategy to me. But Barnes and Noble had its own ideas. They preferred a single volume, expansive and with all three books inside the binding. And by prefer, I mean that they probably wouldn’t stock any of the books if we insisted on bringing out individual titles.

   B&N. That mangled monopoly is like that beefy guy who used to play linebacker in the NFL. He used to be invincible. But five knee surgeries and uncounted concussions later, he isn’t what he used to be. Yet the man still has mass and quick-twitch muscles, and the giant can still stand and come at you with an attitude that made millionaire quarterbacks piss their pants.

   Barnes and Noble wanted a single fat volume, and there was a specific word total that would make them oh-so-happy. In the meantime, I had rewritten the first novel, adding necessary material. And the second novel — THE CORONA’S CHILDREN — was nearly finished: A bigger story with more points of view and plenty of action, and by action, I mean that my work left me shaken, drained.

   Between the two books, I had already used up 70 percent of my word allotment.

   Now, I suppose it would be fashionable to bitch about publishing and bloodless bookkeepers. But the many delays with the DIAMOND project gave me time and the urge to contemplate a bigger tale, epic and human and sorry and inevitable. Years of idle thought have given me plenty of material and one very clear direction for the Great Ship story. Word totals can seem draconian, but consider this: Every painting has its frame. Each frames defines a rectangle that always looks small against the universe. And it’s up to the artist to fill that very limited, very ordinary rectangle with a mesmerizing complication of paint and light.

   My initial plans for a big final novel had to be discarded.

   I needed something with sinews and muscle and nothing else.

   That’s why I wrote an outline, of sorts. I was cobbling together ideas for a narrower, cleaner story. Only critical POVs were allowed to have voices. I would try to keep the action centered on one location at a time, most of my characters close enough to hold hands. (With an exception or two, as needed.) Narrow stories are usually easier than big wide-open spectacles, and I have a reasonable feel for word totals and timetables. And it didn’t hurt that in the midst of that outlining process, I found that phrase: “Memory of Sky.”

   I set to work, and good things kept happening. Potential story problems loomed in the distance, but they were hallucinations, all of them vanishing as I arrived. I had momentum and clear goals, and best yet, I had my title.

   Then a week before Christmas, my mother-in-law died.

   This was a sudden death. She was ill, but not in this way. I didn’t sleep one night, and then starting the next morning, I had to drive a couple hours every day, visiting the funeral home and the family farm, plus being an only parent while my wife dealt with her tragedy. But despite exhaustion and distractions, I wrote almost every day. I wrote more words than usual, and later, examining that work in the light of a new year, I didn’t have much to complain about. Words came rushing out of me, and when I did sleep, I dreamed the story, and maybe it was exhaustion and distractions that did the trick. Maybe it was Death hanging over my world. But most likely, it’s because I have been doing this work for my entire adult life, and the story was in my bones, and with so much mayhem around me, I was able to relish a piece of fiction as it came to its end.


   According to the latest scheme, a novel built in three pieces will come to the shelves at Barnes and Noble next year, probably in the spring. will sell it, of course.

   Epub markets and the independent bookstores too.

— Thanks so much for your interest,
— Robert Reed

April 4, 2013

[April 2012 -- Some thoughts on my course during the shifting winds of the current publishing industry.]

Generous Possibilities

   In its details, the universe is one unplanned mess.

   That doesn’t mean there aren’t guiding laws and grand principles. Hydrogen stays loyal to its nature, neutrinos cling to theirs. Space has a flavor and quality that seem to hold sway over billions of light years, and all the while time doggedly runs in just one direction.

   But suppose the universe started again. Shove every sliver of energy back where it began and watch the drama unfold: Thirteen billion years later, everything will look familiar and nothing will be the same. There will be rocks and there will be galaxies, but none of them will be in exactly the same place. Our faces and histories and social security numbers won’t evolve again—not in a second roll of the die, at least.

   Screw grand principles. What defines us is the arbitrary-this and the happenstance-that.

   For example, consider my Great Ship universe.

Marrow book cover   Quite a few years ago, I wrote “The Remoras” as a stand-alone story. Its success inspired another two stories—“Aeon’s Child” and “Marrow”. The latter was nominated for a Hugo, and that novella became a novel with the same title. MARROW made money. It didn’t make anybody rich, but this writer enjoyed a reliable income for several years, and its mild triumph allowed me to build another couple novels for the same publisher. One of those novels, THE WELL OF STARS, was a sequel to MARROW, and it did respectable business. But it didn’t perform quite like its sibling, and a stand-alone novel, SISTER ALICE, was thrown into the world with a stock cover and no backing. My sales figures were dropping, and in the modern world, dropping is very bad news.

   I wrote a several-page proposal for a sequel to THE WELL OF STARS. It would have been a very exciting story, I’m sure. But there were troubles involving sales and projections of sales and the presence of new talents in the SF universe that hadn’t worn out their welcome. My former editor sat on the proposal for a long, long while. I heard promises that something was about to happen, while quite a bit of nothing was happening. The proverbial years passed. I was busy writing Great Ship stories for magazines and anthologies. I wrote other stories, including “A Billion Eves,” which won a Hugo in 2007. But the dynamic proposal for a work of stellar wonder and grand, time-spanning adventure was doomed to languish until nobody remembered what it was about.

   I know I don’t remember the story, which by the way is not an altogether bad bit of news.

   Back when I first began getting paid for my work, wise voices told me that winning a Hugo, any Hugo, added so many tens of thousands of dollars to your advance. Maybe in the 80s, such talk wasn’t crazy talk. I wouldn’t know. But I have never gotten tens of thousands, and publishing has changed in so many ways since then. Today I know a lot of Hugo winners. Quite a few of us are lucky to have a spouse who is gainfully employed. I am very, very fortunate that my wife has a reliable income and that we live in a community with inexpensive housing and quality schools. I’m also blessed to have editors who want my shorter stories and a cadre of fans who appreciate whatever the hell it is that I am doing with my words.

   Writers can be prickly sorts. At Denvention 3 in 2008, I found myself getting extra pissed about the turns of my writing life. It had been years since I sold any novel, and I was flinging around for some strategy that would put me back on the racks as a book-builder. A couple editors decided to help with advice: Write a YA novel. Young adults like YA novels, and a lot of their parents liked them too. They cautioned that I had to steer clear of sex, but after that I could do pretty much anything I wanted. And not only was that good sound advice, but it was delivered at a moment when the target—me—was in a receptive mood.

   I went home and wrote a YA novel, which is to say, I went home and thought long about what I wanted in the story. I needed a kid that interested me, and I needed him in a situation that intrigued me, and I wanted to put him at the center of action that would set up ripe territory for sequels and future characters. I decided to use the Great Ship universe. I started playing with notions about innocence and ignorance and the shape of everything. As memory serves, all this preparatory work consumed most of a year, and only then did I finally put electric words into a tiny folder on my hard-drive.

   Time flowed and the book came along nicely, and I had hopes about it, which is never a bad thing while working on any book. At least I was enjoying the boy and his various miseries. Perhaps it wasn’t exactly a YA novel, what with implications being half-buried in the text—an unfortunate mainstream habit of mine. And the drama didn’t exactly come rushing out of the gate, at least not in the way that certain people might want. But by chance, exactly as I was finishing up the first full draft, a different editor at my former publisher contacted me on an unrelated matter.

   We chatted on the phone. He had read my earlier work and said good words. I admitted that I was about done with a new book, and he told me that he wanted to read it. I sent it to him first. He enjoyed it and was very interested, and it seemed that things were going to happen at long last. The editor only needed that right sweet perfect moment to ask his boss for the money and the sales force that would make the investment pay off.

   Unfortunately, that moment never arrived.

   Eventually the editor went to work elsewhere. I work with him now, on matters which can’t be discussed today. But my point is: I don’t blame him or doubt his convictions to my efforts. I wrote what I wanted to write, and the industry has its tastes and needs. My tastes are not average, I have been told, and more time passed. But by letting the work sit in a computer file, unobserved, it had a chance to age and grow, and more importantly, I was able to apply thirty years of writing experience to the business of making my novel into the first chapter of one sweeping wondrous and occasionally heroic tale.

   Today’s publishing industry is ruled by chaos.

   Chaos’ chief agent is Amazon. For a little while, Amazon has been searching for titles to publish, and with my permission, my agent sent the manuscript to them. Soon an offer was made. But there were delays brought on by a lot of issues, and a lot of questions on my part. I mean, I own an e-reader. It’s a Nook. And if I went with Amazon, I wouldn’t be able to read my own novel on the Nook, which seemed like a peculiar circumstance, and that made me slow to sign the contract on my desk.

Prime Books Logo   Enter another random event: I was trading e-mails with Sean Wallace at Prime Books. Again, this was about some other matter. But because a good editor is always on the prowl, Sean asked if I had anything in the way of new novels. I did. I have two. There’s a second book that I wrote recently, but it’s huge and demands patience from the reader and I have no clear plan yet on how to sell it. (Perhaps it will be something offered from me directly, as electrical impulses across the Web.) Anyway, while holding Amazon at arm’s length, I sent the book to Sean, and he wanted it and the next two novels in the series that I was proposing to do, and we came to terms relatively quickly, and he wants all three books finished inside the next year, and I feel guilty for spending these moments on a chatty monologue that doesn’t really help put Diamond where he needs to be.

   DIAMOND was the working title for the first novel. Most likely that will change in the next little while.

   The setting is the universe of the Great Ship, and that’s all that I’m prepared to say on that subject for now.

   As for how many books would finish the story…I don’t know, and I don’t want to waste time thinking about it.

   But here stands the point of this piece: Every universe is a shambles, unruly and inept and definitely in need of a good combing. The good story that I was going to write after THE WELL OF STARS has been lost, but my circumstances have given me the time and motivation to reappraise what I want to do. The Great Ship and Marrow and the characters sitting at the heart of this big long venture are part of their own shambling universe, and this is where I will likely finish out my writing career. And because I am a story-telling ape, it is possible to believe that everything that has happened has been a blessing: The weakness of publishing in general and a bad cover on SISTER ALICE were strokes of good fortune that gave me the opportunity to tell an epic adventure that is entirely mine. Or it could also be that a bunch of crap happened in our world, and I’m drawing neat lines where I want lines to be.

   That second explanation is less human and more plausible.

   Whatever the reasons or whatever the lack of reasons, I wrote 80,000 words about a lonely boy living inside a single room, and he is locked inside that room for what seems like good reasons, and there is a world past the heavy door, but you won’t learn anything about that world until the summer of 2013.

   Barring another unforeseen dose of chaos, of course.

-- Robert Reed

April 6, 2012

Addendum, March 2013:

The publishing industry being what it is -- somewhat fickle and prone to numerous changes related to long-term plans -- several things have changed related to the publishing deals Bob wrote about above. The latest news was encapsulated in the introduction to "Precious Mental" in the June 2013 issue of Asimov's as follows: Robert Reed tells us that his planned trilogy with Prime Books is still a trilogy, but will be published as a single volume, perhaps in April of 2014. The working title is The Memory of Sky. Bob is also planning to "self-published a collection of Great Ship stories called The Greatship. Yes, one word. Each story has been slightly reworked, and there is new bridge material, and not only will this be available as an e-pub, but there will be a POD version as well." The collection won't include his 2012 or 2013 material.

Scott Edelman accepts Robert Reed's Hugo award at the 2007 WorldCon[September 2007 -- "A Billion Eves" wins the Hugo Award for Best Novella at Nippon 2007. Here were the acceptance notes given to Scott Edelman to read on Bob's behalf --]


   First of all, I am surprised. Very surprised. If I were a betting man, I wouldn’t have given myself one chance in ten of winning this amazing honor. My thanks go out to NIPPON 2007 and WorldCon 65, and to those quirky souls who voted for this year’s Hugos. Sheila Williams, the editor of ASIMOV’S SCIENCE FICTION, saw the potential of this story, and she has my eternal gratitude. And I must praise that good magazine’s former editor, Gardner Dozois, for his long-time support of my goofy, galloping ideas.

   At this moment, I’d like to repeat the truism that science fiction is memorable because of its ideas. And nifty ideas translated into short fiction seem to be far more infectious than those notions that are buried deep inside the convoluted plotlines of novels and series of novels. Without your support—and by support, I mean your money—the short-fiction markets will continue to wither. Our best talents, being creative souls, will eventually find other outlets. But something important will be diminished, if not lost altogether. And I don’t see why that should make any of us happy.

   Finally, I’d like to thank my wife, Leslie, for her endless encouragement, and my representative at NIPPON 2007, Scott Edelman, for his gracious help and good humor.

   Best wishes, and pleasant nightmares.

-- Robert Reed

[The novelette "Roxie" appeared in the July 2007 issue of Asimov's.]

[May 2007]

   I walked my dog the other night.

   This happens once or twice a month. In the past, she usually acts young and strong, racing up and down our stairs or straining at the leash to chase rabbits. But there always comes that moment when I think to myself, "God, you're in great shape, girl. Considering you're dead." And then I pop awake, my heart kicking and my nerves frayed.

   But my last dream involved an older, somewhat heavier dog. Our walk was lazy and happy, and about midway through, I remembered that she was gone. But I didn't wake up. Instead, we took a lap together in the park, and I eventually drifted out of sleep without fuss or regrets.

   Roxie died almost exactly a year ago.

   This photograph was taken in 2002, on our back patio. By me, I believe.

   Think what you will about the heavy steel chain, but she broke free of it at least twice.

-- Robert Reed

Watch for additional messages on this site directly from Bob in the future...

Return to the Main Robert Reed page



Complete Bibliography



Forthcoming Works






The Word from Bob


This page last updated: October 10, 2016